News from ISA

28

In memoriam: Bruce Russett (1935-2023)

We have lost a mentor, collaborator, and friend. Bruce Russett died on September 22, 2023, in Hamden, Connecticut at the age of 88. He was Dean Acheson Professor of International Politics at Yale University, where he was an active faculty member from 1962 To 2009 and where, after his retirement, he held a research professorship. Bruce was one of the leading lights of the scientific turn in international relations scholarship. His body of work, which included some truly pioneering contributions incorporating ideas and approaches from the field of economics, addressed an exceptionally diverse range of substantive, theoretical, methodological, and normative questions. Of these, he is best known to the contemporary discipline for his elaboration and extension of democratic peace theory. His influence on so many aspects of the field was felt in many other ways through his training of graduate students, his service to the profession – for example, as president of both the Peace Science Society (1977-79) and the International Studies Association (1983-84) – and, not least, his editorship of the Journal of Conflict Resolution from 1973 to 2009.

A graduate of Williams College, with a bachelor’s degree in political economy (1956), Bruce Russett received a graduate diploma in economics from King’s College, Cambridge (1957), before attending Yale, where he earned his Ph.D. in political science in 1961. Those early years were formative. His background in economics made him a good fit at Yale, where Robert Dahl and Karl Deutsch were at the forefront of what would become known as the “behavioral revolution” in political science, an effort to apply the scientific method to the study of politics. As his dissertation advisor, Deutsch’s influence on Bruce was profound. His dissertation picked up on themes in Deutsch’s pathbreaking work on international integration and security communities, leading to his first book, Community and Contention: Britain and America in the Twentieth Century (1963).

After serving one year as an instructor at MIT, Bruce returned to Yale in 1962 as an assistant professor of political science. There he remained a member of the faculty for the entirety of his academic career, though he also received a number of visiting appointments, including at Columbia, Michigan, Harvard, Free University of Brussels, Soviet Academy of Sciences, Netherlands Institute of Advanced Study, Tel Aviv University, and the University of Tokyo Law School. Continuing his collaboration with Deutsch at Yale, Bruce directed the World Data Analysis Program, which released the first edition of the World Handbook of Political and Social Indicators in 1964. Along with the Correlates of War Project at Michigan, the program at Yale paved the way for a new generation of scholars engaged in quantitative research in international relations and comparative politics.

A subject that Bruce would return to frequently throughout his career was deterrence. In “The Calculus of Deterrence” (Journal of Conflict Resolution 1963), he was the first to subject the prevailing rational-choice approaches to a systematic empirical analysis of the conditions contributing to a state’s ability to deter an attack on an ally. Bruce was equally concerned with the ethics of deterrence, especially the central moral quandary of nuclear deterrence: how can we threaten to do something that would be morally unacceptable actually to do? His Catholic faith, scholarship, and ethical concerns came together when he served as principal advisor to the U.S. National Conference of Catholic Bishops, which issued its influential Pastoral Letter on War and Peace in 1983. The Letter boldly challenged the legitimacy of any use of nuclear weapons and raised significant moral questions about nuclear deterrent threats. Coming at a time of heightened cold war tensions and a renewal of the nuclear arms race, the Letter received attention far beyond the confines of the Catholic Church and contributed to the broader public discourse on the dangers of the superpowers’ military postures and policies. Bruce’s concern with the civilian consequences of armed conflict, especially for women and children, also led to pioneering work from the perspective of public health published in the American Political Science Review (2003) and Social Science and Medicine (2004).

Bruce’s work on the Pastoral Letter was not the first time he turned his academic expertise and ethical commitments to a critique of American military policy. In No Clear and Present Danger (1972), while many scholars were questioning the U.S. war in Vietnam, Bruce dared also to challenge the conventional wisdom that Japan’s attack on Pearl Harbor in 1941 provided an unambiguous and immediate reason for the country to join World War II. Much of the reaction to this book was harsh, and not unexpected, but it showed Bruce’s courage as a scholar. He did not shrink from controversy when he thought our understanding of the world could be advanced by considering unconventional subjects, arguments, and approaches.

Much of Bruce’s scholarship focused on various influences of the domestic environment on the national security policy of the United States, and vice versa, including the award-winning What Price Vigilance? The Burdens of National Defense (1970), as well as Military Force and American Society (1973), and Controlling the Sword: The Democratic Governance of National Security (1990). Here again, he was a pioneer; this work started appearing when the discipline was still preoccupied with strictly international interactions, like war, arms races, and balances or imbalances of power.

Bruce’s most significant and enduring contribution to the discipline is his work on the “democratic peace” – the theory that democracies rarely resort to war with each other. The theory did not originate with Bruce; it can be traced back to Immanuel Kant’s essay, “Perpetual Peace.” Nor was Bruce the first to subject the notion to empirical testing. But no scholar did more to theorize, test, refine, and extend the democratic peace, or to debate its merits with critics. It became one of the discipline’s most recognizable research programs. Grasping the Democratic Peace (1993) was Bruce’s first comprehensive statement on the subject, and it brought within a single work he had been doing with various colleagues. He continued to advance the research program from there by integrating the pacific effects of economic ties and participation in institutions of global governance, both of which Kant also anticipated. This “Kantian Peace” was the subject of Triangulating Peace: Democracy, Interdependence, and International Organizations (2001). The book won the International Studies Association’s prize for the best book of the decade.

Throughout his career, Bruce Russett published, individually or with co-authors, more than 250 articles and chapters and 28 books, including a textbook, World Politics: The Menu for Choice, which appeared in ten editions. It was one of the first undergraduate textbooks to link theory and research, interweaving concepts across levels of analysis and providing sophisticated introductions to such key concepts as the principal-agent problem, interdependence, collective goods, and tragedy of the commons. Bruce believed that educating undergraduates required not only communicating what we think we know about world politics, but also why we think we know it.

But for all his accomplishments and stature in the discipline, what we have lost most with Bruce’s passing is a remarkable human being. He was unfailingly attentive to his graduate students and his mentorship, for us and others, led to rewarding scholarly collaborations and to valued friendships. But countless other young scholars, who were not his students, benefited from Bruce’s generosity and genuine interest in their ideas, research, and progress. We say goodbye to one of the greats, an inspiration to so many of us.

 

Harvey Starr, University of South Carolina
David Kinsella, Portland State University
Paul Huth, University of Maryland
Charles L. Taylor, Virginia Tech

Posted in: Headquarters

Comments

Susan Bryant
Thursday, October 12, 2023 9:06 AM
Professor Russet was a wonderful teacher and a great mind. I benefitted immensely from his wisdom and his eternal patience, while I was at Yale in the mid-1990s. I am sorry to hear of his passing. Sue Bryant

Join the Discussion...
Only registered users may post comments.

        

ISA on Twitter

Search

Newsletter Archive

Check out our newsletter archives here!

Archive

May 2024 (10)
April 2024 (4)
March 2024 (2)
February 2024 (3)
January 2024 (3)
December 2023 (2)
October 2023 (2)
September 2023 (9)
August 2023 (5)
July 2023 (7)
June 2023 (8)
May 2023 (10)
April 2023 (7)
March 2023 (7)
February 2023 (4)
January 2023 (5)
December 2022 (5)
November 2022 (3)
October 2022 (6)
September 2022 (7)
August 2022 (6)
July 2022 (4)
June 2022 (7)
May 2022 (9)
April 2022 (5)
March 2022 (6)
February 2022 (7)
January 2022 (3)
December 2021 (4)
November 2021 (8)
October 2021 (10)
September 2021 (7)
August 2021 (6)
July 2021 (2)
June 2021 (6)
May 2021 (5)
April 2021 (3)
March 2021 (2)
February 2021 (4)
January 2021 (6)
December 2020 (7)
November 2020 (3)
October 2020 (2)
September 2020 (4)
August 2020 (6)
July 2020 (5)
June 2020 (4)
May 2020 (11)
April 2020 (3)
March 2020 (9)
February 2020 (8)
January 2020 (3)
December 2019 (2)
November 2019 (3)
October 2019 (5)
September 2019 (6)
August 2019 (4)
July 2019 (3)
June 2019 (4)
May 2019 (11)
April 2019 (14)
March 2019 (7)
February 2019 (4)
January 2019 (5)
December 2018 (7)
November 2018 (2)
October 2018 (8)
September 2018 (8)
August 2018 (11)
July 2018 (8)
June 2018 (9)
May 2018 (10)
April 2018 (4)
March 2018 (1)
February 2018 (6)
January 2018 (1)
December 2017 (6)
November 2017 (1)
October 2017 (2)
September 2017 (11)
August 2017 (7)
July 2017 (10)
June 2017 (15)
May 2017 (13)
April 2017 (12)
March 2017 (8)
February 2017 (20)
January 2017 (9)
December 2016 (6)
November 2016 (8)
October 2016 (10)
September 2016 (19)
August 2016 (11)
July 2016 (14)
June 2016 (14)
May 2016 (19)
April 2016 (19)
March 2016 (11)
February 2016 (5)
January 2016 (11)
December 2015 (14)
November 2015 (8)
October 2015 (4)
September 2015 (15)
August 2015 (11)
July 2015 (16)
June 2015 (8)
May 2015 (15)
April 2015 (19)
March 2015 (14)
February 2015 (7)
January 2015 (9)
December 2014 (10)
November 2014 (4)
October 2014 (14)
September 2014 (12)
August 2014 (13)
July 2014 (8)
June 2014 (6)
May 2014 (16)
April 2014 (17)
March 2014 (8)
February 2014 (15)
January 2014 (9)
December 2013 (12)
November 2013 (9)
October 2013 (20)
September 2013 (24)
August 2013 (13)
July 2013 (8)
June 2013 (11)
May 2013 (5)
April 2013 (11)
March 2013 (3)
January 2013 (1)